As you may have noticed music snobbery is rife. Extremists shouting in support of their thing, and ready to leap to social media to tell you why your thing is rubbish. I’m not getting into the is X or Y artist Prog debate here because, frankly, I have a life.
The 70s output of Blue Note Records has been seen, mostly by those for whom Jazz froze in 1962, as way inferior to the “heyday” of the 50s and 60s. My taste in Jazz was largely informed by The Kyle Cathie book ‘Jazz on CD‘ by John Fordham. This introduced me to Hank Mobley, Lee Morgan and many others. What it skipped over was anything that crossed over into fusion, funk or rock. Bill Bruford’s excellent Earthworks was dismissed, more seriously so was Miles Davis after 1969. The Mahavishnu Orchestra got a brief mention under John McLaughlin, who himself only merited a 20 word bio and 1 album suggestion, from 1969. Even in the mid 90s there was a healthy cd reissue market so that’s not an excuse.
So, until very recently I missed out on the 1970’s at Blue Note. I picked up Donald Byrd’s ‘Street Lady’ at a charity shop, and it’s great. If you are of the view that Fender killed Jazz with their Rhodes Piano and Precision Bass then try this, and the rest of the Mizell Brothers‘ productions for Blue Note, and other labels. A friend then reminded me about Quantic Soul Orchestra and introduced me to guitarist Wilbert Longmire, who doesn’t rate a Wikipedia entry it seems, but try his ‘Sunny Side Up‘ album. Jazz Funk, or Fusion, or whatever has therefore entered my life giving me something new to look out for. The couple of compilations I have bought suggest the quality is much higher than my previous prejudice would have allowed for. Why Steely Dan never found Longmire I’m not sure he would have fitted them like a glove.
Now, on second thoughts I am getting into the Prog or not thing. The doyen of Prog writers, Sid Smith, has recently pointed out on Twitter some of the hypocrisy surrounding the magazine of the same name, as well as the lack of actual progression in much of the music that calls itself “Progressive”. By the numbers Genesis and Pink Floyd retreads do seem to dominate, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t some good music within the rough confines of Prog. Prog Magazine itself seems to be less worried about the definition than their readers, embracing everything from material that is closer to Folk to electronic music of the Tangerine Dream type.
Duke Ellington is credited with saying “There are two kinds of music. Good music, and the other kind”. The rest of the quote from an article called ‘Where Is Jazz Going?’ in Music Journal from 1962 is … “the only yardstick by which the result should be judged is simply that of how it sounds. If it sounds good it’s successful; if it doesn’t it has failed.” For me the definition extends far enough to include, if it makes you feel good it doesn’t matter what label it carries or what other people think of it.
